Preview

Ronald Takaki a Different Mirr

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
951 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ronald Takaki a Different Mirr
American identity has been created by many events throughout the course of history. This country was founded on the clashing and mixing of many different cultures and lifestyles. One of the most important periods of time for this country was during the period of conflict between Americans and Native Americans over land rights. Americans had an idea of manifest destiny and that this land was theirs for the taking. The Americans were going to walk through anyone who opposed them in this quest for land. The treatment of the Indians during this time period was harsh, cruel, and violent to say the least. It is in this treatment that Americans came to view the Indians as a "racialized other" and where race began to matter. This early thinking is what created our American identity which is based on race. In the early settling of this country, when the English first encountered the Indians they viewed them as uncivilized beasts. "The first English colonizers in the New World found that the Indians reminded them of the Irish" (Takaki, 28). To the English the Irish represented a lower and uncivilized class of people, a group that the English considered to be beneath them. This association was the beginning of creating an "Indian Race." The Indians were different then Irish in they had a reddish tint to their skin. This was important because this lead further to their separation by their color. The Indians were further looked at as savages based on their culture. "They were seen as incapable of becoming civilized because of their race" (Takaki, 36). This thinking lead to the belief that the Indians were worthless and simply impeding the spreading of a civilized culture. Indians from this point began to be dehumanized even further. Due to the color of their skin they were associated with the Devil. The settlers believed that Indians must be removed in order to progress in the settling of our land. "God was making room for the colonists and hath

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The idea of getting the Indians to moves elsewhere came about on May 30, 1830. The government which was Andrew Jackson and his fellow workers came up with a movement called the Indian Removal Act. This act evicted 46,000 Indians from their property and to move west. Nobody liked the Indians and the government never took them serious. The Indian act was great move to the whites because it left 25 million acres of land. Socially the white seen this as a gain because they needed more land to produce food and slavery. Racism played a big part in the Indian Removal Act. This act helps us understand how landscape played a big part in forming the culture and environment people back then had to adopt to. The Indian Act affected us today because we are treated second to white any…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ap Dbq List

    • 5047 Words
    • 21 Pages

    2. Attempting to coerce Indians into adopting white ways, the government passed the Dawes Act, which eliminated…

    • 5047 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indian Stereotypes

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One of the biggest stereotypes of Indian tribes is non-Indians believe that all Indians are alike. Unlike most people think of Indians, Indian tribes are consisted of 511 different tribes, recognized by the federal government and additional 200 unrecognized tribes. Mostly medias are the biggest contributor of implanting these stereotypes of Indian tribe members. Indian tribes wear big feathery headdresses, have body paints, live in tipis, make war cry sound to communicate, worship natures, and so on. Before the European arrival, there were more a thousand different Indian tribes and they spoke that many languages and dialects.…

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Indians had their own customs and religions. They were introduced to the colonist’s religion, Protestant Christianity. They did not immediately take to the Puritan religion as the Indians took to Catholicism brought in by the Spaniards. They found it difficult to embrace a religion that taught that all but a few of them were damned to hellfire. Also, the Puritan or Anglican religion was complicated with English ways of eating, dressing, working, and looking at the world. The Indians that did embrace the Protestant religion were forced to adhere to the Protestant ways and abandoned their own. The Indian men were to farm and the women to weave, they lived in English houses and not wigwams, they were to barber their hair as the Puritans, and they were to stop using bear grease toward off mosquitoes.…

    • 1275 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the many myths that the Europeans created about the Native Americans is that they are bloodthirsty, ruthless savages. Oliver La Farge does a good job in his essay of discounting this myth by giving multiple examples of how most groups of Native Americans were a peaceful group of people that just were not quite as well developed socially, economically, technologically, etc. as the Europeans. Because of this lack of development on behalf of the Native Americans, the Europeans looked at the Native Americans as uncivilized savages. The reason that this myth was even created was to justify the slaughtering of thousands of Native Americans at the hands of the Europeans, with the justification being that they were inferior beings, which is another myth brought up. Once the Europeans had conquered the Native Americans, this myth was altered, now proclaiming that the Native Americans were drunken, lazy good-for-nothings. La Farge also discounts this part of the myth in his essay. Going back to the point of the Europeans thinking they were superior a superior race when being compared to the Native Americans, that would happen in any situation if the circumstances were similar because it is human nature to believe that if one race able to conquer another race, then they will believe they are superior. This is one of the continuing myths that have hid…

    • 767 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American identity involves the freedom to do what you want along with the ability to express yourself in every way imaginable, but unfortunately this is not the reality for people immigrating to our country.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Issue Common Identity

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The questions that is asked to personally answer in this discussion is do I agree or disagree that Americans need a common identity. I agree with Michael Walzer’s, the man in the textbook, opinion; No, Americans do not need common identity. My opinion is why chance America from the way it was and still is; especially, if America is not doing any harm the way it is. D’Angelo and Dougals (2011) stated that European was the first people to immigrant to America [during the 17th century]. That statement tells me that multiculturalism is what America always has been. Immigration has been the primary cause of the growth of the American population from a little less than 4 million in 1790 to over 270 million in 2000 (Hirschman, 2005, para. 18). If it was not for multiculturalism (immigrants) Americans would have over half of the things they have today. For example, over half of American’s vehicles such as Nissan, Honda, Volkswagen and Mazda are made oversea. Nissan’s, Mazda’s and Honda’s vehicles are made in Japan while Volkswagens are made in Germany. Overall, 50% of Americans buy these vehicles. Canada, Mexico, and China import the most of America’s products. Petroleum products, passenger cars, aluminums, and lumbers are the most items Canada imports to America. We all use these items or have used these items before. Crude oil, car parts, video equipment such as DVD players, and electrical parts are the most things Mexico imports to America. Over 80% of American has DVD players in their home. China imports a lot of things to America such as computers, miscellaneous household goods, toys, household furniture, and footwear. Look at all the things listed that we get from China, there is no way we can do without China’s items. If American has a common identity, we would never be the same. We will not have over half of the things have. In my opinion, if is not broke do not try to fix it.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    How Does Racism Affect Today

    • 3643 Words
    • 15 Pages

    For example, Ernest Renan stated that the 'blacks' of Africa, the aborigines of Australia, and the 'Indians’ of America were all people who belonged to this 'inferior' race, whereas all the others belonged to the 'superior' white race. When Christopher Columbus set out on his historic journey, and discovered what he then named 'Indians’, he was in fact surprised that these were also people, just like the Europeans that he was familiar with until then. However, these indigenous people were considered to be more 'animals' without a soul, than human beings, and they were eliminated as was seen fit at that time, today, there are very few of these Native Americans in existence any…

    • 3643 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    While Native Americans have a rich cultural history, much of this culture has been destroyed or manipulated to favor the European-descended majority. American Indians were portrayed as vicious, bloodthirsty savages who stubbornly resisted religion, education, and acculturation. Some examples would be the frequent references to the practice of scalping enemies, burning enemy camps, and enslaving enemy women and children. In addition, references to Native Americans’ pagan-like religions and native languages contributed to the demonization by European settlers.…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Erik Erikson, a well-known psychologist, defined identity as “the creation of a sense of sameness, a unity of personality now felt by the individual and recognized by others as having consistency in time-of being, as it were, an irreversible historical fact.” (Bowles, 1993). There must be a component in society, for an individual to become part of it, with which they can relate; and this highlights the issue of race and ethnicity. This idea has turned out to be exceptionally delicate in the current past to the degree that it evokes stress in many regions. While studying the society of the United State with regards to its cosmopolitan characteristics and the lifestyle of people, it was found that America is of diverse cultures including multiple…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How We Define Ourselves

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Americans come from many different backgrounds and nationalities. Of these Americans are different races and religions, which represent the United States today. With the amount of diverse people in the United States, not everyone agrees with allowing people of different races and religions to mix. Living with people of different cultures can have a major impact on peoples’ lives. People today define themselves and others by the way they look and the things they may do or say. Things such as: Black, White, upper class, lower class, Northerner, Southerner, and Immigrant start to become the labels of others. Everyday people are judged by things such as these cultural characteristics. The different ethnicities in America start to break apart from a whole and become their own. America must learn to become one and stop defining each other separately.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the first chapter of “A Different Mirror” by Ronald Takaki, he explains stereotypes and biases of white, Eurocentric attitudes that have been with us since the earliest days of the colonies and settlements here. Beginning with the early colonists and their treatment of the natives, there is a pattern of ruthless acquisition of land and goods. According to Takaki, the early settlers judged native americans as lacking everything identifiable in a civilized society. It never occurred to them that the natives had never been exposed to their european “civilized” ways and did not have knowledge of sophisticated weaponry as their culture did not need such devices of destruction. They did have tools and means of hunting and gathering food but it was all quite unsophisticated compared to european advancements.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Is Racism So Common

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When the European settlers came to North America, they came with a promise of peace, yet time soon revealed differently. They took the children of the inhabitants (like the Indians and natives) and separated them from their family and people. They were beaten and punished like dogs when they showed signs of their culture (language) and were harassed (raped). They were looked down for their ethnic backgrounds, skin color, language and traditions.…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In chapter 17 of the book, A Different Mirror, written by Ronald Takaki, he discusses what Bill Clinton said in 1997 during his presidency. Clinton says one day we will all be minorities and there will be no majority race in America. He believes this because of all the people who have come from all over to America. In our lecture on April 18th, we discussed the previous film we watched, Come See the Paradise. We also discussed some of the key terms and went over some if anyone had questions. We then were introduced to our next film, The Joy Luck Club. The lecture on April 27th, we mainly discussed previous readings in our text and the movie we just finished. We also went over a preview of the final things due for the course. The film, The Joy…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    American Is a Salad Bowl

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The identity of America has changed from when the Indians came from Europe to America in 18th century. Where you live has a major affect on your identity from the north to the south. America has defined themselves not by race, religious, and ethnic identity but by common values and individual freedom. America is a salad bowl because there are all different kinds of races, religions, and people from different countries. An individual’s identity is created by where they came from. Everyone comes from different backgrounds. From state to state, everything is different. America is mixed with all different cultures and races. Your identity is created by where you grew up, gender, and your education.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays