Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

In what ways is Dead Poets Society about the conflict between realism and idealism?

Good Essays
610 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
In what ways is Dead Poets Society about the conflict between realism and idealism?
Society as we know, has been shaped by numerous conflicts in the past, some between nations, some between races, and some between the interests and issues of certain people. Dead Poets Society in particular, is about the conflict between realism and idealism. For example Welton Academy is a school that is deep-rooted in realism, the teachers are all realists and in turn did not allow the students to think for themselves, but taught them what they thought was necessary. The students, being young, have ideals but were never able to realise them. All it took was Keating with his idealism to show the students to think for themselves. This set off a massive chain reaction. Neil's death in particular was a example of the conflict between realism and idealism. Knox Overstreet's infatuation with Chris was also an example between realism and idealism, but to a lesser extent.

Firstly, Neil's conflict between realism and idealism was between his acting and his fathers interests. In Neil's views, acting was all he wanted to do. He did not want to go to Harvard, become a doctor, or anything his father wants him to do. That was his ideal reality. In his father's view, he only wanted Neil to succeed in school, to go to Harvard, and to become a doctor, so he would not let Neil be distracted from his main becoming a doctor. That was Neil's reality. But even though his ideals were forbidden by his father, he still went after it, against his father's wishes. But when his father found out, and was denied any further chances to act as a result of him transferring to another school, he could not take his current reality. He could not handle his conflict between his reality and his ideals, so he committed suicide.

Knox Overstreet's infatuation with Chris is another example of a conflict between realism and idealism. In that, in his ideals, he is going out with Chris, but in reality, she is already with someone. Therein lies his conflict. Knox tries to make his ideals happen by incessantly courting her by giving her gifts, going to her parties, but his ideals are never realized, because of his conflict between realism and idealism.

Keating's ideals of teaching his students to think for themselves conflict with the interests of the teachers, especially Mr. Nolan. Keating's origins from Welton Academy may have influenced him to be so interested in his student's futures and dreams. So he wants to teach them how to think for themselves, so that they can those dreams and futures happen. But in reality, the headmaster, Mr. Nolan completely disagrees with him. In saying that he is too much of an idealist, and that teaching seventeen year olds to think for themselves is absurd. Keating still went ahead and taught his students what he thought was necessary to think for themselves, even though it was against the wishes of the headmaster. In doing so, he set off a massive chain reaction, which may have lead to the death of Neil, and lead to his sacking. His ideals cost him a student, and his job.

In many ways, Dead Poets Society is about the conflict between realism and idealism. All the characters in Dead Poets Society is based around this; Neil's conflict between his acting and his father destroyed him; Knox's infatuation with Chris can't be realized because she is already with someone and Keating's ambitious quest to teach his students to think for themselves ended in the death of Neil. The human world is based around conflict of numerous sorts, and Dead Poets Society is a shining example of the conflict between realism and idealism.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    * The first reason I believe that realism is exemplified is the way in which the story is set up: two men engaging in conversation, with basic and general mannerisms for the era and time which it takes place. Also, realism also usually reflects dialect and culture (as can naturalism) which is clearly portrayed. “Well, thish-yer Smiley…”(Lauter 58) and “I’ve got my opinion, and I’ll resk forty dollars that he can outjump ary frog in Calaveras county” (Lauter 59) are both examples of dialect.…

    • 275 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In A Separate Peace and Dead Poets Society, some of the characters in the book seem like others in the movie. Gene, one of these characters, in the Separate Peace, relates to Tom in Dead Poets Society, and Phineas or Finny, in the Separate Peace, relates to Neil, in Dead Poets Society. Gene thinks he is at fault with anything he is involved in where something bad happens, and Tom thinks he is worth less and bad at everything. Gene and Tom both look down at themselves. Gene and Tom’s parents are uncaring. Gene talks but mainly only to Finny. Tom only talks to Neil, when he talks to others he is embarrassed and usually quiet. They are both quiet except to their roommate Finny or Neil. Gene was upset when finny fell off the tree and shattered…

    • 242 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    His tenacity to try and make life his, is what drove him and what maintained his outward appearance. His father, though forcing him to do as he says creates turmoil inside Neil leading to a collapse of his hope. This creates a very finite array of solutions which pushes him to commit suicide as an easy way, to get away from his father.…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dead Poets Society and A Separate Peace are similar stories in many ways, both stories are also very different in multiple ways.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Iwt Task 1

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Realism was painted to depict real life situations. It was developed by artists to create an illustration of common people and un-extraordinary circumstance. According to the facts in Wikipedia in regards to Realism, it was an attempt to be as photographic as possible without a camera. Realism was a revolt to the more emotionally driven Romanticism art where fantasy escaped onto canvas via the paintbrush. Realism is truthful, without fancy and ornamentation.…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

    • 4427 Words
    • 18 Pages

    Realism was a theatre movement that came to the forefront in the early 20th Century. It was the theory of Naturalism put into practice. It aimed to take a ‘slice of life', as such, and reproduce it on the stage. The proscenium arch acted as the fourth wall of a room, and the audience looked into this ‘laboratory-type' set up and examined what may happen to a real person.…

    • 4427 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    To most people a dream is just a part of the imagination, of course it would be ideal for it to come true, but the average person can see the difference from a dream to reality. The average person knows not to trust people blindly, knows to do what is best for them, they understand that occasionally one must put their dreams aside for it will not work with the world around them, they understand how to adjust their dream to reality. Of course this is just the average person. The characters Finny and Neil are both dreamers and idealists and were therefore destined to die for they could not live in a world where dreams are only dreams and reality includes hate, jealousy and practicalists. Finny was unable to live a life where his best friend hated him. Neil was in able of living a life in military school. Both could only live the dream.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Idealists said that true reality involved ideas rather than the world as perceived by the senses…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The film, “Dead Poets Society,” directed by Peter Weir, is a classic example of conformity versus nonconformity. Its main appeal is in the passionate acting of Robin Williams, who plays John Keating, an inspiring teacher with unusual methods. Inspiring co-stars Robert Sean Leonard and Ethan Hawke play Neil and Todd, students enrolled in the school Keating teaches at. The film is set in a very strict all boys school that has many rules and guidelines, yet undoubtedly the boys, inspired by Mr. Keating, begin to rebel against the structure and authority. Peter Weir uses a number of film techniques to develop this theme of conformity versus nonconformity. The importance of these techniques is revealed in the film through the use of setting, sound…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Idealism describes the belief or pursuit of a perfect vision often based upon unrealistic principles. This pursuit is often contrasted and opposed by truth. The truth and reality in an individual’s life is what enables this person to remain grounded and down to earth. An individual must set themselves high expectations in order to be their best, but they must also acknowledge the fact that everything they desire is not achievable. The imbalance of idealism and truth in an individual’s life can have calamitous effects. It is significant in an individual’s life because it can lead to the deterioration of an individual’s sanity, destruction of family relationships and ultimately death. This is exemplified in Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, by Willy Loman. Willy spends his whole life pursuing the American Dream. This pursuit leaves him in debt and lacking less than a sliver of sanity. This man lacks the capacity to face the truth; the reality of his situation. The negative effect that his dream has on his family and life is simply overlooked and ignored. As Willy’s life swerves out of control, he tumbles deeper into the abyss of his idealism, to a point of no return.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ‘Carpe Diem!’, literally translating to seize the day, is a concept most in the film Dead Poets Society attempt to adhere to. Set in 1959, the boys take this latin mantra to heart after being first introduced to it by Mr Keating. This then becomes the prime factor of motivation for most, if not all, of their actions in the film. Although the outcomes are positive on occasion, with an unbiased mind, their physical actions and choices would easily be seen as selfish and naive. As an example, throughout the entire film, Neil Perry endeavours to follow his dreams of acting against his father’s will.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the movie, Neil Perry’s parents make it very clear that they want Neil to advance to medical school after high school. Neil’s dad was very headstrong throughout the movie, showing how he wants neil to quit his extra curricular activities and strictly focus on his studies. Howver,Neil is the type of character that was interested in the arts. Deep inside he knew that he did not want to become a doctor and wanted to advance in theater throughout the future. Neil had a main part in the play presented by the town.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the long history of debate over idealism and materialism in consideration, it would be inappropriate to dictate which one is right or wrong. Between these two doctrines, there is a ‘thing’ that has differentiates one from the other; in other words, this thing completely separates idealism and materialism. Though veiled in mystery, this thing tells us at least that idealism and materialism are inharmonious doctrines. It would be misleading to make a compromise between those two concepts as our distressful world has demonstrated so far. The Great Gatsby reveals what this thing is.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As realist theory evolved, it split in to two schools of thought based primarily on different views of root cause of conflict. Classic realism is associated with Morgenthau and other realists who are pessimistic about human…

    • 1646 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie was quite not new to me since I’ve watched it several times when I was still in high school during our overnight. But I must admit that the impact of this movie to me has never changed from the moment that I personally have watched it. It was a very realistic movie that touched my heart all over again. Indeed, when we are young we really are curious about things and would actually see for ourselves on something. Mr. Keating, the teacher encourages his students to take chances and think outside the box. He is an ideal teacher to me because his purpose of being a teacher is not just to teach them the concepts but to teach them something that could be use for their future. He inspires his students to explore new things for it is indeed in doing so that you get to explore yourself and know your capacities & limitations. Mr. Keating reminds me a lot of my math teacher way back in high school. He is also a very comic but a strict man. Since, I am really poor in math I really refused studying the subject. But when I met this teacher, my outlook towards the subject has changed. He made me realize that if you want to achieve something, you have to do everything that you can so that at the end even if you succeed or fail, you can proudly say that you did your best despite of and you’ll have no regrets. Also, he made me realize that grades are really not what matters most but what you have learned. We have to do our best in every thing that we do all for God’s greater glory. The movie is very suitable for us, teenagers since we are in the stage in finding out who we really are, what we really want and who we want to be. The movie encourages us to be the students who aren’t afraid of taking risks but at the same time with every action that we do we are responsible for it. Comes with the great power to choose for ourselves is also the great responsibility to act accordingly for the betterment of the…

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays